Skip to content
Tudor Hilcu THG Conseil

The first 48 hours of a crisis, on one page

On 1 August 2012, in about 45 minutes, Knight Capital built up billions of dollars of stock positions it never meant to take. In the end, the broker lost more than $460 million. According to the SEC, it had no procedures to guide its staff through a serious incident. Who decides, who speaks, who does what: the answer fits on one page, written on a calm day.

Author
Tudor HilcuFounder & CEO, THG Conseil
Published
Reading time
9 min
Topics
Crisis, Governance
Contents7

On Wednesday 1 August 2012, as the New York Stock Exchange opened, Knight Capital’s order-routing system ran out of control. In about 45 minutes, it obtained more than 4 million executions in 154 stocks. The final loss came to more than $460 million. The technical trigger is well known: during an update, one server out of eight had been missed.

What interests me here is what came next. According to the order published by the SEC, the US securities regulator, Knight had no procedures to guide its staff when a serious problem arose. That day, Knight relied mainly on its technology team to find the fault in a live market, and its system sent out millions of orders while the team was still searching.

At moments like that, nobody has time to work out who decides. The answer has to exist beforehand. It is one of the tools I give business owners: the first 48 hours of a crisis, on one page. Below: what Knight had to settle within a few days, then the page line by line, and how to keep it up to date.

Five days to decide everything

On Wednesday 1 August, the incident itself: according to the SEC, one of the fixes attempted during live trading made the problem worse instead of solving it.

On Thursday 2 August, Knight issued a press release. It said what had happened, that the software at fault had been removed, and that all the erroneous positions had been closed out, for a realised pre-tax loss of about $440 million. It also said that its capital base had been severely hit, that it would continue its trading and market-making activities from the open that day, and that the company was actively pursuing its strategic and financing alternatives.

On Monday 6 August, Knight announced $400 million in equity financing from several Wall Street firms. In return, they received preferred shares representing, once converted, about 73% of the outstanding common stock. A deal of that size would normally have required shareholder approval under the New York Stock Exchange’s rules. The board’s Finance and Audit Committee judged that waiting for it would seriously jeopardise the company’s financial viability, and the exchange did not object.

In five days, Knight had to answer three questions: who decides, who speaks, and who does what while everything is on fire. I am not saying that a page would have saved Knight. I am saying that these three questions come up in every crisis, at an SME as much as at a Wall Street broker, and that they are best settled in advance, while things are calm.

The full story of the missed server is in the article on the Knight Capital case.

The page: three lines, then the numbers

A cyberattack, a fire, a major customer who stops paying, management software that will not respond on a Monday morning: the causes vary, but the first hours look alike. Everyone calls everyone, and each person waits for someone else to decide. The page is there so that everyone already knows who that someone is.

1. Who decides: a name, and a stand-in

Write down a name, not a job title. “Management” does not pick up the phone. Write down a stand-in too: a crisis gives no warning, and on the day itself, the managing director may be on a plane, on holiday or out of reach.

Add what this person can decide alone, without a meeting: shut down a system, close a site, suspend deliveries, commit spending up to an amount you set in advance. The SEC makes the point about Knight: its technology staff needed clear guidance on when to pull a malfunctioning system off the market. The first decision in a crisis is often to stop whatever is making it worse, and only then to look for the cause.

2. Who speaks: one person for staff, customers and the bank

Staff, customers and the bank need to hear the same thing, from the same person. Two versions doing the rounds often do more damage to trust than the incident itself. Everyone else points people to this person, with a ready-made line, for example: “I can’t answer that, but Inès will call you back before noon.”

The first message comes down to four points: what has happened, what we do not know yet, what is being done, and when the next update will be. Knight’s release of 2 August, which followed an earlier announcement of the incident, covers part of it: what happened, what it cost, what would carry on, what the company was looking for. It says neither what was still unknown nor when the next update would come. Those are precisely the two lines not to leave out.

3. Who does what: the first three actions, each with a name

Three actions, not thirty. Each one has a name and a deadline. Most of the time they come down to protecting people, stopping whatever is making things worse, and telling those who need to know.

At the bottom: the useful numbers, on paper

The insurer, with the policy number and the assistance line. The bank: your account manager and their stand-in. The accountant. The lawyer. The IT provider, with its emergency line if it has one.

For a business in France, add two public reference points. In a cyberattack, 17cyber.gouv.fr, the online assistance service run by the French national police, the gendarmerie and Cybermalveillance.gouv.fr; in an emergency, 17 or 112. If personal data is affected, the GDPR requires the breach to be notified to the supervisory authority, the CNIL in France, without undue delay: where feasible, no later than 72 hours after becoming aware of it. The one exception: a breach that is unlikely to result in a risk to people’s rights and freedoms. Write that deadline on the page, and in the very first hours check what applies to you with your lawyer and your accountant.

Why on paper? Because the day IT goes down, the contacts go down with it: the email, the directory, the software where the numbers are stored. The printed sheet is still there.

Where to keep it, and when to reread it

One copy in a drawer, one on your phone, as a photo or a PDF, so that it does not depend on the company’s systems. Give one to your stand-in as well.

Reread it once a year with your team, and whenever a name changes: someone leaves, a new bank, a new insurer, a new provider. Use the review to call every number once. Better to find out on a calm day that a number no longer answers.

Fictitious example: the page of a 25-person manufacturing SME
Block On the page
Who decides Claire, the managing director. Stand-in: Thomas, production manager. What they can decide alone, without a meeting: shut down the workshop, suspend shipments, commit up to €10,000.
Who speaks Inès, head of administration and finance, for staff, customers and the bank. Line for everyone else: “Inès will call you back before noon.”
Who does what (management software down) 1. Karim calls the IT provider before 8.30 am. 2. Thomas moves the day’s production orders onto numbered paper forms. 3. Inès contacts the ten largest customers before 10 am: what is happening, how to place an order, next update at 2 pm.
Useful numbers Insurer and policy number, account manager and stand-in, accountant, lawyer, IT provider’s emergency line, 17cyber.gouv.fr. Personal data affected: CNIL, within 72 hours where feasible.

One page, four blocks, and first names everywhere. On the Monday the software stops responding, nobody wonders who does what: the page already says.

What I learnt

In 2020, the premium sports club I had been running in Paris since 2015 was closed overnight by government order. The announcement caught me off guard: the handover with my coaches, state support, keeping track of the finances, I had to organise it all in a rush. When we reopened, we had to rebuild everything, and the club held on. The details are in the full story of the club’s closure.

What I take from it: whatever you settle while things are calm, you don’t have to make up under pressure.

The limits of this case

The facts about Knight come from the SEC’s order and press release of 16 October 2013, and from two press releases and a Form 8-K filed by Knight with the SEC in August 2012. Knight accepted the order without admitting or denying its findings. The 45 minutes are the time during which the positions built up; the loss was realised afterwards, when Knight closed them out. The figure differs by source: about $440 million before tax in Knight’s release of 2 August, more than $460 million in the SEC’s order. No source says that a crisis procedure would have prevented the loss. The SEC does say that a written procedure requiring a simple double-check of the deployment could have caught the missed server and averted the events of 1 August (paragraph 41 of the order): that is a different procedure, further upstream. I stick to the questions the incident raised. The CNIL and 17Cyber reference points are French, and were checked on 24 and 25 October 2026; for your own situation, go through them with your lawyer and your accountant.

Where to start this week

  • Take a sheet of paper and write three headings: who decides, who speaks, who does what.
  • Fill in the first two with names, and the names of their stand-ins.
  • For the third, take the most likely breakdown in your business (management software, a cyberattack, a major customer who stops paying) and write three actions, each with a name and a time.
  • Write the five useful numbers at the bottom of the page, print it, and take a photo of it.

Half an hour, and the first hour of your next crisis is already decided.

On the day everything stops, it is too late to decide who decides.

To go further, the module The crisis on one page includes this first-48-hours sheet, along with an Excel workbook to spot your critical suppliers, watch ten warning signs and keep a log of decisions. When a crisis hits cash, the 13-week cash flow plan tells you how many weeks you can hold out. All the documents are free to download on the Resources page. I have worked with some fifty companies. Coming through a crisis explains how I work. The first conversation is free, by phone and in strict confidence, within 48 hours: call me or write to me, on +33 6 74 86 88 70 or at contact@thgconseil.fr. In a crisis, call directly: the conversation and the intervention contract happen within 2 hours.

Sources

Facts checked on 24 and 25 October 2026 against the original sources.

Is something holding you back?

Call me or write to me. The first conversation is complimentary, and I reply within 48 hours.

Take the rapid assessment

Four questions, two minutes. Nothing is sent or stored.

By phone:+33 6 74 86 88 70WhatsAppEmail