Skip to content
Tudor Hilcu THG Conseil

Carillion: more dividends than cash

Carillion, a British construction and services giant, raised its dividend every year for sixteen years. Between January 2012 and June 2017, it paid out £333 million more in dividends than its operations generated in cash, before going into liquidation in January 2018. The same mechanism can play out, on a smaller scale, in an SME that pays out a good profit while its customers pay late.

Author
Tudor HilcuFounder & CEO, THG Conseil
Published
Reading time
9 min
Topics
Cash, Dividends, Crisis
Contents9

On 15 January 2018, a British court ordered the compulsory liquidation of Carillion, on a petition from its own directors. The group built roads and hospitals, served school meals and managed accommodation for the armed forces. It employed more than 40,000 people.

The report of the House of Commons committees, published on 16 May 2018, pulls no punches. Carillion went into liquidation with liabilities of nearly £7 billion and just £29 million in cash. It owed around £2 billion to its 30,000 suppliers, sub-contractors and other short-term creditors, who will get little back. The government had already committed £150 million to keep essential public services running. In June 2018, the National Audit Office reported that the loss on the liquidation for the government was then estimated at £148 million, and that the total cost to the taxpayer would be higher.

The most striking part is not the collapse itself. It is that in March 2017, ten months earlier, Carillion was still announcing a record dividend. This is case study no. 04 in my LinkedIn series; here is the full version, with its sources.

A dividend that rose every year, come what may

In its last annual report, published in March 2017, Carillion noted with pride that it had increased its dividend in each of the 16 years since it was formed in 1999. The MPs found that the dividend bore little relation to very volatile results. In 2012 and 2013, more cash went out than came in, as construction volumes fell. The board still raised the dividend.

The House of Commons Library did the sums from the group’s accounts. From 2009 to 2016, dividends took three quarters of the cash generated by operations. Between January 2012 and June 2017, Carillion paid out £333 million more in dividends than that cash. Yet cash from operations also has to pay for investment and for interest on debt. Over a similar period, from 2011 to 2016, the group paid £441 million in dividends, against £246 million to reduce the deficit in its pension schemes.

On 1 March 2017, the 2016 accounts looked reassuring. On the back of those results, Carillion paid a record dividend of £79 million. The final payment of that dividend, £55 million, went out in June. In January, the finance director had proposed holding back that £55 million, to conserve cash and reduce debt. Two directors opposed him: they were worried about the message it would send to the market. The £55 million was paid.

On 10 July 2017, Carillion announced an £845 million reduction in the value of its contracts and suspended its dividend. In September, the write-down rose to £1,045 million, the equivalent of the previous seven years’ profits combined. Liquidation came six months after that first warning.

A dash for cash, funded by debt

Over those years, debt kept climbing. According to the House of Commons Library, the group’s borrowing rose from £242 million in December 2009 to an estimated £1.3 billion in January 2018, more than five times as much.

The MPs also point to acquisitions. They cite Eaga, a supplier of heating and renewable energy services bought in 2011. The deal cost Carillion £298 million. Five consecutive years of losses followed, £260 million in total by the end of 2016.

The MPs summed up the cause in a single sentence: a relentless dash for cash, driven by acquisitions, rising debt, expansion into new markets and the exploitation of suppliers. Paying out more in dividends than the company generated in cash, despite the borrowing, low investment and a growing pension deficit: they wrote that they could find no justification for it.

Suppliers as a quiet line of credit

Carillion had signed the UK Prompt Payment Code, yet it imposed standard payment terms of 120 days on its suppliers, cut to 45 days if they sold their invoice to its bank at a discount. For the MPs, this arrangement gave Carillion a line of credit, which it used to shore up a fragile balance sheet. The credit rating agency S&P Global told the committees that the lack of transparency around these practices had probably obscured the weakness of its balance sheet and cash flow.

You may be tired, too, of funding a large customer who pays when it suits them. The Monday rule tells this story from the suppliers’ side, sets out the payment terms that apply in France and gives you the tool for spotting late payments before they bite; the article on unpaid invoices covers the safeguards to put in place before you start. Here, I stay with the owner’s own decision: the dividend.

What this case says about dividends

Profit is measured in the accounts. A dividend is paid with money that leaves the bank. When the two drift apart for several years running, the gap gets financed somewhere: by debt, by the cash already in hand, or by suppliers.

Very long payment terms turn suppliers into the company’s lenders. They are not paid for that role, and they are often the smallest.

An SME is not the size of Carillion, but the mechanism is the same. Paying a dividend on a good result while customers pay late means funding it from the cash in hand or from the bank. And a dividend sends a message, to your shareholders and to your banker alike. Carillion chose to keep paying rather than send the wrong signal. The real signal came in July 2017.

Five points to check before paying a dividend

  1. Compare the dividend with the cash generated by the business, not just with profit. For the year, and for the two or three before it. Ask your accountant for this figure: they can work it out from your accounts.
  2. First take off what the cash already has to pay for. Loan repayments and planned investment come before any payout.
  3. Look at what falls due in the next three months. Salaries, social security contributions and taxes, suppliers, loan repayments.
  4. List the late payments of your five largest customers, and your own supplier payment times. A receivable that is overdue is cash you do not have yet. If you are stretching your suppliers to stay afloat, write it down: it is a warning sign.
  5. Settle the amount with your lawyer and your accountant. They will tell you what can be distributed. It is up to you to judge what the cash can pay without hurting the business.
Fictitious example, in round figures: an SME’s check before approving its dividend
Line Amount
Profit for the year €300,000
Cash generated by the business over the year €120,000
Loan repayments due next year €40,000
Cash available for a payout €80,000
Proposed dividend €200,000
Share of the dividend not covered €120,000

On paper, the profit allows the dividend. But the business only generated €120,000 of cash, because two large customers pay late, and €40,000 of that is already needed to repay the loan. The missing €120,000 would come out of the cash already in hand, or from new borrowing. The owner reviews the amount with the company’s lawyer and accountant, after looking at what falls due over the next three months.

With €280,000 of cash generated, €240,000 would have been left once the loan was repaid: the business would have covered the dividend, and the decision could have been taken with peace of mind.

What I learnt

From 2015 to 2021, I ran a premium sports club in Paris. It showed me that payroll has to be met every month, and that cash is something you watch closely. In 2020, we had to close overnight by government order, and the club held on.

On an ERP and WMS programme for a large group, I managed the budget working directly with financial control: forecasts, accruals, sign-offs, payments, receipts. On every assignment, I also handled the supplier contracts, down to penalties and refunds. What has been committed and what has been paid are two different figures. It is the second one that keeps a company going.

To my mind, a dividend should be decided on the cash flow forecast first, and the profit and loss account second.

The limits of this case

The £333 million figure is a calculation by the House of Commons Library, based on Carillion’s accounts; it does not appear in the summary of the committees’ report. The £2 billion owed to suppliers and creditors comes from the last published balance sheet, at 30 June 2017. On payment times, the last finance director gave different figures: an average of 43 days in 2017, according to the Library’s briefing, and about 5% of the supply chain paid after more than 120 days, according to the MPs’ report (the Library’s briefing says “in 120 days”). The 120 days were the standard terms imposed, not an average. The harsh judgements quoted come from the MPs: they are their conclusions, not court rulings, and I do not apportion individual responsibility. UK company law is not French company law: for a dividend or payment terms in your own company, take it up with your lawyer and your accountant.

What to take back to your business

  • This week, set the cash generated by the business against the dividends paid, for each of the last three financial years.
  • List your five largest customers with their actual payment times, not the contractual ones. Do the same for your five largest suppliers.
  • Every Monday, write down the balance of all your accounts on a single line.
  • Before the general meeting that approves your accounts, write down your payout rule, for example: no dividend beyond the cash generated by the business, once loan repayments and planned investment are covered. Have it checked by your lawyer and your accountant. Do it before the vote: once a dividend has been paid, that cash has left the business.
  • Reread your terms of sale: do they state your payment period and your late payment penalties?

The first line takes an hour with your accounts, or one call to your accountant: it is enough to tell whether your dividend is paid for by the business or by your cash reserves.

A dividend is paid with cash, not with a profit figure.

The previous case, Notre-Dame de Paris, shows a building project that stayed on budget and on time. To track your cash week by week, the Cash under control module and the 13-week cash flow plan template download in one click, with no sign-up, like every document on the Resources page; the article on the 13-week plan explains how to update it every Friday, alongside the Monday check. If cash is already tight, Coming through a crisis explains how I work; to build, with your accountant, a plan whose cash flow accounts for your payouts and your investment, see Growth. In all, I have supported some fifty companies, in audiovisual, construction, energy, e-commerce and multi-business groups. The first conversation is free, by phone and in confidence, within 48 hours: +33 6 74 86 88 70, contact@thgconseil.fr, or the Contact page. In a crisis, call me directly: the conversation and the intervention contract happen within 2 hours.

Sources

Facts checked on 24 October 2026 against documents from the House of Commons, its Library and the National Audit Office. That day, the UK Parliament website was refusing automated reading tools: some of its documents were read in the copies kept by the Internet Archive.

Is something holding you back?

Call me or write to me. The first conversation is complimentary, and I reply within 48 hours.

Take the rapid assessment

Four questions, two minutes. Nothing is sent or stored.

By phone:+33 6 74 86 88 70WhatsAppEmail